Oakland County-based fast-food chains Papa Romano's
Enterprises Inc. and Mr. Pita Franchise Corp. hope a new
merger and foray into co-branding will give them a stronger
foothold as the companies eye a national expansion in 2008.
Restaurant analysts say combining two brands under one roof
can make marketing and economic sense and follows a model
that proved successful for larger chains including Pizza
Hut, KFC and Taco Bell.
But
they say the two companies, whose pizza delivery and pita
sandwich footprints are concentrated entirely in Michigan,
could find it difficult to grow their brands and succeed
beyond state lines.
The
companies plan to launch their new co-brand later this year
by retrofitting a number of existing Mr. Pita and Papa
Romano's stores, said Casey Askar, chairman and CEO for the
two companies.
He
declined to specify expansion plans but said the companies
are targeting markets in the Midwest, South and East Coast
and would release plans in the first quarter of 2008.
Askar
said the companies identified multiple existing locations
for co-branding, adding that the stores "will have a new
look, new equipment and that's all in the works."
The
chains enlisted the services of St. Louis-based Moosylvania
Marketing. Both brands also have opened new prototype
stores: a Papa Romano's on West Eisenhower Parkway in Ann
Arbor and a Mr. Pita on Van Dyke near 15 Mile in Sterling
Heights.
"It's
a great fit because (with) Pita, the majority is daytime
lunch business, and pizza in general is a nighttime-weekend
business," Askar said.
The
privately held companies together employ about 1,000 and
have seen combined year-to-date revenues of about $34
million, he said. Both brands have seen growth in sales,
including double-digit growth at some Papa Romano's stores
for the first time in five years, he said.
"On
the job level, we have hired on more field supervisors to
help support a large chain now between the two brands, and
we are growing. We are expanding," Askar said.
Using
the co-branding concept to expand nationally may be what
each company needs to take itself to the next level in a
market still dominated by large hamburger chains, said Ed
Nakfoor, a Birmingham retail consultant.
"It
solves the 'What do you want to have for lunch' dilemma,'"
he said.
But
expanding nationally may be a "quantum leap" for the
Michigan-based chains, said Jerry McVety, a Farmington Hills
restaurant consultant. A safer bet might be to target a more
regional expansion into nearby states before going national,
he said.
"I
think franchising the wrap and the pizza concept, because
there's so much competition out there, is going to be
difficult to do," McVety said. "The wrap, in my opinion, is
just another type of sub sandwich."
The
companies announced Oct. 10 they had merged to realize cost
savings and economies of scale by combining purchasing,
advertising, corporate staffing and other operations. The
merger was made official Aug. 1 and included relocating Mr.
Pita from Shelby Township to Papa Romano's corporate
headquarters in Commerce Township, Askar said. Mr. Pita
founder Frank Lombardo also was named president of both
companies and will oversee day-to-day operations.
The
co-branding concept can help businesses "in that the issues
of being able to build two restaurants for the price of
one-and-a-half are real," said Ken Batali, who runs a
restaurant-consulting firm near Seattle. "You get to share
bathrooms and equipment, and those are the real expensive
parts of opening up a restaurant."
The
risk, said Batali, who was not familiar with either company,
is that co-branded chains could cannibalize each other's
business. Both chains offer salads, while Papa Romano's menu
lists subs and Mr. Pita serves pita pizzas.
"A
good location is usually a good location for anything,"
Batali said. "If it takes a great location and splits a
great business, they never get as much business as two
separate units would."
Askar,
38, purchased Papa Romano's in February from founder Ronald
Hancock and took over management of the chain in May. The
company, which began in Southfield in 1970, has since opened
three new stores and purchased five franchises to operate as
the first corporate stores, he said.
Lombardo, a former Little Caesars franchisee, launched Mr.
Pita in 1993 in Sterling Heights.
Papa Romano's currently has 53 stores
in Michigan while Mr. Pita operates 35.